HSX Forum

Movies

I guess I got confused when you brought Kaku into the discussion, as he is not mentioned nor the subject of the articles in the OP.

Posted by: BSmurf on Oct 08, 07:19 in response to elchan's post Um, there's always one side of the Moon that faces Earth....

I'm also curious how being known in the scientific community and trying to popularize science makes one a "pop scientist" and somehow invalidates their knowledge or expertise.

Kaku graduated from Harvard and has a Ph.D in Physics from UC Berkeley. He's a reknowned professor and researcher of theoretical physics. Hardly an irrelevant qualification for commenting on the physics and motions of how stuff happens in space.

He has also done a good amount of science promotion on television, film, radio, and in books. I fail to see how being a more visible public figure makes his opinion less worthy.

This would be like arguing the Stephen Hawking was less intelligent or reputable because he is popularly well known outside of his scientific field of knowledge.Ā 

A physicist and an astronaut fact-check GRVTY Antibody Oct 07, 14:00

I was unaware this was intended to be a documentary. {nm} Bubba_Fett Oct 07, 14:47

Do you believe a movie can transform our world? {nm} Richard In G Oct 07, 14:50

for some reason I saw "a physicist and an astronaut walk into a bar" :) {nm} tealfan Oct 07, 15:03

at least Buzz Aldrin liked it... tealfan Oct 07, 15:05

Degrasse-Tyson also liked it (quite a bit). He just pointed out where the science wasn't perfect. {nm} Dales Oct 07, 15:22

Scientific opinions of these "pop scientists" aren't worth the paper their degrees are printed on. {nm} elchan Oct 07, 15:55

Did you read them? One was an actual astronaut who has been on shuttle missions. Hardly a "pop scientist". Tyson is well-regarded too. BSmurf Oct 07, 16:28

internet courage makes one strong {nm} Moviesnob Oct 07, 17:28

He's the one that got Pluto downgraded. These guys are publicity hounds. They don't do real science. elchan Oct 07, 18:08

... you realize that on the moon, it's ALWAYS "full moon" up there, unless it's in the earth's shadow (lunar eclipse) BSmurf Oct 07, 18:20

Um, there's always one side of the Moon that faces Earth. Depending on the phase, it's either lit or not. elchan Oct 07, 22:39

The phase of the moon during the Apollo 11 landing was a waxing crescent heading into first quarter (over a week before full moon) RogerMore Oct 08, 01:01

Yes Apollo 11 landed on 9 days before full moon, so for that one mission it was possible that earthshine was responsible, but not the others {nm} elchan Oct 08, 10:11

No. RogerMore Oct 08, 10:19

I guess I got confused when you brought Kaku into the discussion, as he is not mentioned nor the subject of the articles in the OP. BSmurf Oct 08, 07:19

I'll take scientists with PHDs, even "pop" ones, over anonymous internet person anyday. {nm} Antibody Oct 08, 09:54

Sure, thinking is over-rated. Listen to people who have letters after their names, they're smarter than you. elchan Oct 08, 21:43

You have revealed volumes about yourself with these statements, and probably not in the direction or manner you intended. BSmurf Oct 08, 22:25

Did Bill Nye say anything? -kidding. {nm} socby19 Oct 07, 16:35

Like we need them to tell me the movie looked AMAZING but the script was RIDICULOUS? lol (nm) dominique_d Oct 08, 16:35





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!

Ads disabled on hsx.com


The Catch (TCATC) 150000 63.37 (+0.15)          Planet of the Apes sequel (APES5) 75000 53.69 (+0.13)          The Odyssey (ODYSE) 20000 291.38 (-1.00)          Driver's Ed (DRVED) 150000 2.75 (+0.13)          Incredibles 3 (NCRD3) 20000 381.73 (+0.70)          Frozen III (FROZ3) 20000 319.53 (+0.35)          The Man with the Bag (TMWTB) 1 10.26 (-0.16)          The Man with the Bag (TMWTB) 150000 10.26 (-0.16)          Incredibles 3 (NCRD3) 20000 381.73 (+0.70)          Tuner (TUNER) 150000 3.95 (+0.08)          (Saint) Peter (STPET) 20000 5.65 (+0.68)          Fonda (FONDA) 20000 8.98 (+0.89)          Buddy (BUDDY) 20000 7.09 (+0.71)          White Elephant (WELEP) 20000 17.70 (+1.02)          Supergirl (SUPGR) 5 157.09 (+0.44)          Motor City (MTRCT) 150000 8.60 (+0.12)          Scream 8 (SCRM8) 100 77.71 (-0.08)          Pendulum (PNDLM) 150000 6.57 (-0.50)          Pendulum (PNDLM) 150000 6.57 (-0.50)          Corporate Retreat (CRPRT) 150000 4.29 (-0.02)          Obsession (OBSSN) 150000 22.75 (0.00)          (Saint) Peter (STPET) 150000 5.65 (+0.68)          The Wizard of the Kremlin (WZKRM) 150000 3.49 (+0.03)          (Saint) Peter (STPET) 150000 5.65 (+0.68)          Driver's Ed (DRVED) 150000 2.75 (+0.13)          Buddy (BUDDY) 150000 7.09 (+0.71)          Buddy (BUDDY) 150000 7.09 (+0.71)          White Elephant (WELEP) 150000 17.70 (+1.02)          White Elephant (WELEP) 150000 17.70 (+1.02)          Mortal Kombat II (MKMB2) 150000 100.40 (-0.94)          The Super Mario Galaxy Movie $39 (MARI2.BW) 25000 13.39 (+0.07)          Fonda (FONDA) 150000 8.98 (+0.89)          Fonda (FONDA) 150000 8.98 (+0.89)          Octet (OCTET) 150000 20.66 (+0.66)          Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Ve (ASPD3) 2 234.41 (0.00)          Peter Asher: Everywhere Man (PAEWM) 100000 0.87 (-0.13)          The Man with the Bag (TMWTB) 58845 10.26 (-0.16)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 (PRAD2) 50000 200.50 (-0.66)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 (PRAD2) 150000 200.50 (-0.66)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 50000 5.66 (-0.11)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 150000 5.66 (-0.11)          Tom and Jerry: Forbidden Compass (TMJR2) 1000 19.16 (+0.02)          Clayface (CLAYF) 100 86.81 (+0.08)          Octet (OCTET) 673 20.66 (+0.66)          Silent Friend (SLNTF) 1000 0.34 (-0.01)          Death of a Salesman (DOASM) 100 8.46 (0.00)          Jack of Spades (JACSP) 100 6.86 (0.00)          (Saint) Peter (STPET) 20000 5.65 (+0.68)          Buddy (BUDDY) 20000 7.09 (+0.71)          Fonda (FONDA) 20000 8.98 (+0.89)