HSX Forum

Movies

I think this is incorrect. Long explanation inside.

Posted by: RogerMore on Dec 29, 07:50 in response to JohnErleVan's post In Ian Fleming's books, for starters, and in every...

When Fleming first started writing the books, he wanted to create a bland dull character.  There were two reasons for this - he wanted to write spy adventure stories, but he was tired of larger-than-life characters that were the mainstay of British adventure fiction. Instead, he wanted a character who was nothing but a blunt instrument of government policy.  Fleming also realised his character would be more popular if it was a blank canvas that readers could project themselves onto and fantasise about being.

As the books became more popular, their (white, male, English) readers responded to an English hero who - in a time when Britain was losing its empire, was far less important than it was 50 years previously, had just gotten put of food rationing nearly a decade after WW2 had ended, etc - went to exotic places, ate the best food, drank the best wines, met beautiful women. So Bond became more heroic and more about English virtues like bravery, determination, comparisons to St George, etc.  He represented an England who was down, but not out and still fighting. (It was only late in the series when the movies started being made that Fleming retconned Bond to give him a Scottish father - a tribute to Connery - and a Swiss mother.)  He was white because at the time England was overwhelmingly white, and so were his readers.

Fifty years on, England has changed. It has become more open, less sexist, more multicultural, less privileged, less classist, more socially mobile, more questioning, more confident.  Bond's fans include a lot of women, and a lot of non-English people.  And Bond has changed with it - the open racism and smoking of the books has gone, and the benzedrene. Bond is still a sexist womanizer, but he's shown to be out of step, and he doesn't dismiss women as useless as he did in the books.  England will continue to change, and Bond will continue to change with it, and those changes could possibly (and IMO comfortably) include casting a non-white actor in the role.

I see the backlash against the merest possibility of this is not about "being true to the character created by Fleming". It's more about the part of the audience that is white and male wanting to project themselves onto Bond's blank canvas - girls, gadgets, fast cars, beautiful locations, no commitments, all while being being impossibly cool. These fans don't want anything that messes with this - see the hand-wringing at the time of Casino Royale, when the news broke they were casting a blond actor and giving him a Ford Mondeo to drive. Even though non-white Bond fans have been dreaming about being like James Bond for 50 years, these fans are worried that having a black actor in the role will break their fantasy.

Black BOND!!! Idris Elba Had the Perfect Response To People Who Don’t Want A Black Bond Shakarwala Dec 27, 13:38

what do you mean "people"? charlie Dec 27, 14:23

We're 5/6 years(?) off a new JB. If they want the new one leading towards Bond's retirement they might as well keep Daniel Craig [nm] ladybegood Dec 27, 15:53

Craig is a boring, humorless Bond charlie Dec 27, 16:10

BCUMB was born to play Bond, he has to be the next 007. {nm} tatoufan Dec 27, 20:24

eh BCUMB is still a little young. Average age of Bond actors is 42-43. He still got a good 5 years. :) {nm} Dorfman Dec 28, 09:37

What's next, Liam Neeson as Shaft? JohnErleVan Dec 28, 15:07

Where does it say the bond character is, was, or has to be a white dude? That's just how he's always been portrayed. Dorfman Dec 28, 16:49

In Ian Fleming's books, for starters, and in every interpretation of the character so far. JohnErleVan Dec 28, 23:04

I think this is incorrect. Long explanation inside. RogerMore Dec 29, 07:50

I can only speak for myself, but for me it really is about staying true to a character I've known since the 80s JohnErleVan Dec 29, 13:15

Just to be clear, I don't think Fleming wrote Bond as anything other than a white man. But I don't see his whiteness as an essential part of RogerMore Dec 29, 14:58

Race is central to the concept of Shaft. It is in no way relevant to the 'character' of 007. tawdryhepburn Dec 28, 23:24

And since every five star hotel receptionist knows who James Bond is and what he drinks, your IM is kinda moot ;) {nm} RogerMore Dec 29, 06:04

Come to think of it, James Bond is a pretty terrible spy, isn't he? Always uses the same cover and various super-distinctive quirks/ {nm} tawdryhepburn Dec 29, 06:45





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Last Breath (LBRTH) 15000 18.44 (-0.10)          Paddington in Peru (PADT3) 40000 43.42 (-0.16)          Ne Zha 2 (NEZH2) 130048 9.96 (+0.07)          Captain America: Brave New World (CAPA4) 50000 209.67 (-0.65)          Becoming Led Zeppelin (BLZEP) 135025 9.05 (+0.04)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 1 24.21 (-0.02)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 1 24.21 (-0.02)          Cleopatra (CLEOP) 1 35.47 (0.00)          Cleopatra (CLEOP) 1 35.47 (0.00)          Regretting You (RGRTU) 3 36.41 (-0.03)          Regretting You (RGRTU) 3 36.41 (-0.03)          The Gauntlet (GNTLT) 1 39.15 (-0.06)          The Gauntlet (GNTLT) 1 39.15 (-0.06)          The Monkey (MONKY) 3 43.94 (-0.01)          The Monkey (MONKY) 3 43.94 (-0.01)          Fast X Part 2 aka Fast & Furious (FAF11) 1 118.61 (0.00)          Fast X Part 2 aka Fast & Furious (FAF11) 1 118.61 (0.00)          After This Death (AFTDH) 150000 2.14 (-0.12)          Moana (MOAN1) 50000 188.76 (+0.41)          After This Death (AFTDH) 2 2.14 (-0.12)          100 Nights of Hero (100NH) 2 17.58 (-0.68)          100 Nights of Hero (100NH) 2 17.58 (-0.68)          Philly (PHILY) 149998 5.56 (+0.42)          Sicario 3 (SICA3) 149999 7.36 (+0.44)          Dreamquil (DRMQL) 149998 4.52 (+0.58)          Sorry, Baby (SRYBB) 75000 5.82 (-0.05)          I Know What You Did Last Summer (IKNO4) 75000 39.38 (-0.05)          Heart Eyes (HRTEY) 10 29.06 (-1.01)          Barbarella (BARBA) 75000 49.62 (-0.12)          Honey Don't (HDONT) 25000 15.66 (+0.01)          The Smashing Machine (SMACH) 9999 15.64 (+0.04)          Avengers: Secret Wars (AVNG6) 150000 403.10 (+1.53)          Dreamquil (DRMQL) 998 4.52 (+0.58)          Victorian Psycho (VPSYC) 25000 16.31 (+0.96)          100 Nights of Hero (100NH) 50000 17.58 (-0.68)          100 Nights of Hero (100NH) 75000 17.58 (-0.68)          Victorian Psycho (VPSYC) 75000 16.31 (+0.96)          Sneaks (SNEKS) 49999 17.56 (-0.03)          The Roses (TROSE) 150000 11.62 (-0.02)          Sicario 3 (SICA3) 25000 7.36 (+0.44)          Sicario 3 (SICA3) 1 7.36 (+0.44)          Philly (PHILY) 74999 5.56 (+0.42)          After This Death (AFTDH) 74999 2.14 (-0.12)          Heart Eyes (HRTEY) 150000 29.06 (-1.01)          The Order (TORDR) 10 2.13 (-0.01)          Avengers: Secret Wars (AVNG6) 150000 403.10 (+1.53)          The Order (TORDR) 10 2.13 (-0.01)          A Little Prayer (ALPRY) 2 1.16 (-0.01)          A Little Prayer (ALPRY) 2 1.16 (-0.01)          Reminders of Him (RMNDH) 3 17.16 (-0.02)