HSX Forum

Movies

A4J, if you'll forgive me it seems like you over-reacted to too small of a sample.

Posted by: DTravel on Jun 03, 21:47 in response to accountant_4_Jesus' post Your curiosity shall be satisfied. ;)

I'd also remind you that just because someone is the creator doesn't mean they write every episode of a TV series.  I don't expect you remember (or even to say if you do) but I'm curious as to which episodes of Angel and Buffy you did watch because of that and because Whedon wasn't involved in the production of those shows some seasons.

Its kind of like judging Gene Roddenberry on the third season of Star Trek (after Freddy Freiberger took over) and the last seasons of ST:TNG (when Braga and Berman were running the franchise).  I don't expect to change your mind, you're obviously not willing to consider doing so.  I just feel the need to heave my two pennies into the stew.  :)

 

Having seen what other people think of PROME and its box office prospects on opening weekend, I had another look at the all-time R-rated accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 16:21

I agree with your analysis. Now as to legs, I'm wondering, would they depend on it keeping its 3D screens for long? {nm} slappydavid Jun 03, 16:30

I honestly can't see it having much legs, to be honest. accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 16:41

In regards to your unnecessary Whedon slam..... {nm} austpow Jun 03, 17:20

If they had made the ending he wanted, which was the aliens landing on Earth for the final battle, it would have been good. {nm} austpow Jun 03, 17:20

It's not unnecessary. accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 17:41

He also was uncredited cowriiter of Speed. {nm} austpow Jun 03, 18:19

I think I established my point fairly well though that generally, if Joss Whedon is involved, it will bomb or disappoint. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 18:32

As with Avengers? {nm} Facto Jun 03, 18:56

I said generally. That means that there are exceptions to the rule, and I gave reasons for that in my previous comment. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 18:59

I saw that only after. My desktop died tonight, and laptop died three weeks ago. Really odd. Using really slow android/phone now. Blows. {nm} Facto Jun 03, 19:17

Well, he has been busy creating/writing/producing/directing a bunch of tv shows since the late 90's, so that kinda curtailed his output. Paul2k Jun 03, 18:32

The reason why I'm not a fan of his is because almost none of the projects he's involved with I actually like. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 18:33

Curiousity on my part urges me to ask what youv'e seen of his, and what you didn't like about it/them. And I fully respect your opinion. :) {nm} Paul2k Jun 03, 18:39

Your curiosity shall be satisfied. ;) accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 18:58

I'm hardly a geek and I loved both Buffy and Angel, not to mention Firefly and Serenity. Whedon is cerebral, Whedon is God. {nm} Facto Jun 03, 19:23

I'm not going to start a religious argument with you, but I will say that you are wrong in your last statement. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 19:30

There's no accounting for taste. As for who God is, no one knows - but PROME deals with it. Cool for godless Brits, might upset Americans. {nm} Facto Jun 03, 19:37

And I should also add that the attitude of Whedonites (example above) adds to my dislike of his work. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 19:34

Whedon's atheist? I don't know him well, only like what I mentioned, haven't seen it all. I.e. I'm no Whedonite. {nm} Facto Jun 03, 19:44

Someone who says "Whedon is God" is a Whedonite, whether or not they care to admit it. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 19:49

Perhaps, if they mean it:-) From me, it was tongue-in-cheek, and a pun. And PROME-related. {nm} Facto Jun 03, 20:02

Ah, I didn't catch that. Sorry. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 20:05

A4J, if you'll forgive me it seems like you over-reacted to too small of a sample. DTravel Jun 03, 21:47

I remember they were early on in the piece, within the first couple of seasons, so obviously Joss would've still been involved at that time. accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 21:54

I watched the whole of Buffy last year or the year before ... Jane_Citizen Jun 03, 23:40

What do you make of the strength of its opening in the UK compared to SWHTM? (Per: DL). {nm} second gary Jun 03, 16:42

Foreign markets usually watch more movies in 3D than North American moviegoers do, which would add to the box office there. accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 16:50

3.4 million vs 1 million...but both #sare peanuts compared to north america. {nm} forlorne Jun 03, 17:25

if people want to see the movie (unless they are under 17 in the US, and even then . . . ), they won't care about the rating {nm} mickpix Jun 03, 16:46

The only real "buzz" I've heard about this movie has been primarily coming from fans of the original Alien. accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 16:57

But will the teenagers be buying Madagascar 3 tickets and sneaking in to Prometheus? {nm} austpow Jun 03, 17:22

If they do it won't help Prometheus' box office take any. It'll actually boost the box office take of Madagascar 3 instead. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 17:53

Which is why I post ushers on the door to help them find Madagascar when they get lost...like those poor lost zoo occupants. =D Catzan Jun 03, 18:06

*in Maxwell Smart's voice* Good thinking, 99 ;) {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 18:12

I'm not a fanboy. I'm a Fassbenderite, and I'm always hungry for smart sci-fi. Jane_Citizen Jun 03, 22:18

Are you a Fassbenderite because of his acting ability or...? accountant_4_Jesus Jun 03, 22:29

Ehh, a bit of both ... Jane_Citizen Jun 04, 21:23

Good analysis. I have to agree. I want this to be good, but I just can't see it doing that well. {nm} Tanker Jun 03, 16:46

The next step is to admmit you are in denial. I'm not quite there yet, myself. :) {nm} Jane_Citizen Jun 03, 22:19

^^frick, admit. Sticky fingers. {nm} Jane_Citizen Jun 03, 22:20

Unfortunately, I am a fan boy when it comes to Ridley Scott...so I think it looks great whatever the marketing. ;-) Catzan Jun 03, 17:12

Prometheus is at 79% on RT, which indicates that it is good. Fanboys seem to love this. rtbgamer76 Jun 03, 17:18

Its flixster number, though, is only around 37-38,000. And I think we have to concede A4J {nm} second gary Jun 03, 17:31

... 's point that there is a difference between the immediate anticipation for MTRX2 and the more complicated anticipation... second gary Jun 03, 17:33

Hahahaha.. WELL now.. As for RT, look closer. Most fresh reviews are 3/5 or 4/5. Also, the movie *is* sci-fi/horror. No doubt about it. {nm} Facto Jun 03, 18:14

Analysis may be correct, but I think $55M is too low. I think it will do in the mid to high 60's and possible low 70's. elchan Jun 03, 19:21

Few parents should want to see PROME - especially mothers. It's potentially very off-putting to them. When you see it, you'll know why. {nm} Facto Jun 03, 19:29





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Valiant One (VLNT1) 500 6.51 (0.00)          Hourman (HRMAN) 10000 19.14 (-0.02)          Gladiator II (GLAD2) 150000 172.99 (-0.90)          The Horror Fund 9 (SPOOK) 20000 20.25 (+0.21)          Relay (RELAY) 150000 4.09 (+0.73)          Relay (RELAY) 150000 4.09 (+0.73)          The Lost Boys (LOSTB) 150000 2.82 (+0.02)          Yankee Comandante (YANKC) 150000 0.01 (-0.03)          Yankee Comandante (YANKC) 150000 0.01 (-0.03)          Mother Nature (MONAT) 150000 0.86 (+0.01)          Long Day’s Journey Into Night (LDSJN) 150000 0.23 (+0.02)          A Manual for Cleaning Women (AMFCW) 150000 0.27 (+0.01)          Paper Tiger (PTIGR) 150000 20.59 (+1.28)          Paper Tiger (PTIGR) 150000 20.59 (+1.28)          Spa Weekend (SPAWK) 150000 11.84 (+1.84)          Gladiator II (GLAD2) 150000 172.99 (-0.90)          The Bad Guys 2 (TBAD2) 150000 82.39 (+0.41)          Wicked (WICKD) 17672 295.54 (-0.14)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 150000 8.19 (-0.44)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 150000 8.19 (-0.44)          Sneaks (SNEKS) 150000 13.63 (+1.62)          Sneaks (SNEKS) 150000 13.63 (+1.62)          Rainn Wilson (RAWIL) 25000 37.51 (-0.25)          Nick Offerman (NOFFE) 1000 54.04 (+0.84)          Michelle Dockery (MDOCK) 25000 35.61 (0.00)          Wicked (WICKD) 150000 295.54 (-0.14)          Spa Weekend (SPAWK) 150000 11.84 (+1.84)          Top Gun 3 (TOPG3) 2500 229.70 (-0.17)          Spa Weekend (SPAWK) 150000 11.84 (+1.84)          The Matrix 5 (MTRX5) 20000 35.10 (-0.10)          Nick Offerman (NOFFE) 25000 54.04 (+0.84)          The Matrix 5 (MTRX5) 2300 35.10 (-0.10)          The Matrix 5 (MTRX5) 18677 35.10 (-0.10)          Ocean's 14 (OCEN5) 20000 37.27 (-0.17)          Wicked Part 2 (WCKD2) 8714 203.59 (+2.13)          Five Nights at Freddy's 2 (5NAF2) 2000 106.69 (+0.11)          Wicked Part 2 (WCKD2) 8714 203.59 (+2.13)          The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt (LOTR5) 15000 169.22 (-0.08)          A Minecraft Movie (MINEC) 16000 155.83 (+0.25)          Paper Tiger (PTIGR) 20000 20.59 (+1.28)          Wicked (WICKD) 100000 295.54 (-0.14)          Wicked Part 2 (WCKD2) 135490 203.59 (+2.13)          Sneaks (SNEKS) 150000 13.63 (+1.62)          Wicked Part 2 (WCKD2) 5796 203.59 (+2.13)          Jonathan Bailey (JBAIL) 12000 75.99 (+0.62)          Hot Wheels (HOTWH) 149999 14.96 (-0.07)          Ocean's 14 (OCEN5) 149999 37.27 (-0.17)          Star Wars: Dawn of the Jedi (STRW1) 149999 134.99 (-0.75)          Gladiator II (GLAD2) 100000 172.99 (-0.90)          Wicked - Opening Weekend (WICKD.OW) 100000 119.75 (+0.94)